Repair or Replace? Making the Right HVAC Decision

Every homeowner eventually faces this decision: spend money repairing an aging system or invest in new equipment. There's no one-size-fits-all answer, but these guidelines help.

The 50% Rule

If repair costs exceed 50% of replacement cost, replacement usually makes more sense. A $3,000 repair on a system that costs $6,000 to replace tips toward replacement.

The Age Factor

Consider remaining useful life:

• **Under 10 years**: Repair usually makes sense unless costs are extreme
• **10-15 years**: Weigh repair costs against replacement benefits
• **Over 15 years**: Replacement often provides better long-term value

Efficiency Gains

Older systems are significantly less efficient than modern equipment. If your system is 15+ years old, a new unit might be 40-50% more efficient, providing ongoing savings.

Repair History

How often has the system needed repairs? Frequent service calls suggest a system approaching end of life. Money spent on repeated repairs rarely provides good value.

Refrigerant Considerations

Systems using R-22 refrigerant face rising costs as this refrigerant phases out. Replacing with modern equipment using R-410A avoids escalating repair costs.

Comfort Issues

Older systems may technically "work" but provide poor comfort—inconsistent temperatures, humidity problems, or excessive noise. New equipment solves these issues.

The Decision Matrix

**Lean toward repair when:** - System is under 10 years old - Repair cost is under 50% of replacement - First major repair in the system's life - Good maintenance history

**Lean toward replacement when:** - System exceeds 15 years - Repair cost exceeds 50% of replacement - Multiple recent repairs - Using obsolete refrigerant - Comfort problems persist

Getting Good Advice

A trustworthy HVAC company provides honest recommendations. Be wary of contractors who always push replacement—or those who'll repair anything regardless of sense.

We evaluate your specific situation and explain all options. Sometimes we recommend repairs even when replacement might generate more revenue for us. Your long-term satisfaction matters more than any single transaction.

Facing a repair decision? Contact us for an honest assessment and clear explanation of your options.